New Carlisle Ohio

City Wants to Buy Old City Hall Back


New Carlisle City Council voted to authorize City Manager Randy Bridge to negotiate the purchase of the property at 101 South Main Street in New Carlisle.


The building now houses World Threads.


Council Member Ron Cobb objected to the purchase, citing the purchase price of $153,000 plus about $200,000 in needed renovations.


"Now, you've got over $300,000 on a building that's still only worth $153,000. It takes a lot to recoupt the investment that you made in it," said Cobb.


Mayor Ethan Reynolds approved of the purchase, stating, "We've already spent $383,000 in rent, which means we've already paid for this building 2½ times."


Reynolds said that maintenance is not an issue since the City is already paying for maintenance of the building that they are currently renting.


The City is now paying $22,400 annually to rent the current city offices at 331 South Church Street.


The ordinance passed with Cobb as the only negative vote.


World Threads owner Sarah Trimbach, who would be displaced by a purchase by the city, said her options were another location in New Carlisle, a location in Dayton or exclusively online sales.


Council also introduced an ordinance raising Bridge's salary to $80,758.80.


"I think we would have a hard time finding another person as good as [Bridge] that will work for the money," said Council Member Bill Cook.


Council also set a special meeting for Monday, February 27 at 7:00 p.m. to introduce the City's 2019 budget. That meeting will be held at the Smith Park Shelter House.


At a Monday, February 19 meeting of the City Council, Cook introduced a motion to form a Charter Review Committee to determine if changes would be needed to the City's Charter.


The City Charter dictates formation of a Charter Review Committee every eight years. The last Charter Review Committee was formed in 2013. The next Charter Review Committee must be formed in January, 2021.


Council Member Bill Lindsey asked how much this committee would cost the city.


"There normally is no cost until the Charter Review Committee sends their information to us for a ballot issue," said Cook. He also added that costs would be minimal because any ballot issue would appear on the 2020 primary ballot.


City Manager Randy Bridge said that there was nothing to prevent Council from appointing a Charter Review Committee now, but one would still have to be appointed in 2021 to satisfy Charter dictates.


Council Members Cook, Cobb and Mike Lowrey voted for the motion, Lindsey, Reynolds and Council Member Chris Shamy voted against it.


Reynolds said he voted no because of the close proximity of two Charter Review Committees.


In other action, Public Service Director Howard Kitko stated that the city has about two tons of cold patch asphalt and that his crews are filling potholes as they appear.


He said that anyone noticing a pothole on a city street should call the city building at 845-9492, and he would put crews on it as soon as possible.


Bridge announced that asbestos testing of the Madison Street School came back at less than 1%. He said that asbestos removal would cost $38,860.


He said that removal of asbestos in the building would make it more attractive to a prospective buyer.


The public is invited to attend all New Carlisle City Council meetings.


History of 101 S. Main St.


  • The building was built in 1895 to house the Village of New Carlisle offices and the Fire Department.
  • The State building inspectors condemned the Village office building in 1956, forcing officials to move all fire equipment to Smith Park and eventually led to the construction of the new Fire Department building.
  • A newspaper article dated September 19, 1968 stated that the Village was still trying to sell their building.
  • The Village moved into new offices at 432 N. Main St. (the current site of New Carlisle Family Practice) on July 14, 1969.
  • In 1987, 101 S. Main St. was sold by CYKA Investments, Inc. to Carolyn K. Brichacek for $60,000. She, in turn, sold it to Trimbach Investments, Ltd. in 2017 for $74,000 on September 6, 2017. It was then transferred to 101 South Main, LLC, the current owner.